2018 | GEO Pressure Systems Inc.

Cable Encapsulation – Circle or Square?

Which is the Ultimate Shape of a Cable?

Circle-Vs-Square-Encapsulated-Downhole-Cable-Blog-GEO-PSI

Circle or Square

Which is the ultimate shape of a cable? The shape of a downhole cable has serious implications for the success or failure of a downhole system. While both have their own advantages and disadvantages there is only one ultimate cable shape.

Compressional Load

If we apply a compressional load on a piece of wire with a square cross-section, the wire will deform in the middle of the face or will deform into a parallelogram. This is because the majority of the loading is directed through the face and not out to the edges. Apply the same load to a wire with a circular cross-section and you get a very different result; the wire will deform slightly at the middle but the majority of the force is distributed around the cable. This is because when a load is applied to a circle the majority of the force travels down through the arc of a circle.

Tubing-Encapsulated-Downhole-Cable-TEC-Encapsulated-Single-Conductor-Round-vs.-Square-GEO-PSI

Pure Axial Loading

In terms of pure axial loading, a square is 30% stronger in tension. However due to less material being required when producing a circular cable of equal width; the circular wire costs less and is 30% lighter.

Twisting

If the cable becomes twisted a circle is the best shape to resist this. This is because stress concentrations occur at the corner of the square wire, which results in the wire failing quicker.

Bending

A circular wire bends more easily than a square wire. One huge problem with square wire is that depending on the orientation of the wire to the bending motion: the wire will become harder to bend. This can cause problems for storage and deployment. For storage being less able to bend means bigger spools, which means less space to store wire. For deployment being less able to bend means a greater difficulty getting the wire through bends and downhole. It should also be noted that a square wire is far more likely to form kinks than a circle because of the sharp corners on a square.

Conclusion

In conclusion, after years of experience around the world, we have found that round encapsulated downhole cable is superior in nearly all aspects. The increased durability and usability makes it our encapsulation of choice for all applications!

Want to be the first to know? Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Enter your email below and we will send you our latest content directly to your inbox. Be the first to read about topical discussions, and new product releases.

Leave a Reply

five − 2 =

More-Articles-Icon-Two-Documents-Blog-News-GEO-PSI

More Articles

Bare-TEC-Spool-Blog-GEO-PSI
Archive
Jeff Scott

Downhole Instrument Cable: Round vs. Square Encapsulation

Which is the ultimate in performance and durability? The following study was preformed to directly compare 11mm square to 11mm round encapsulation of 4mm Downhole Cable. Various items were studied, including: Manufacturability, Weight, Flexibility, Crush Strength, Cross-Sectional Twisting, Dynamic Friction, and Deployment/Retrieval. Summary Round cable outperforms square cable in weight, flexibility, and crush strength. There

Read More »
Cemented-In-Casing-Systems-Graphic-Blog-GEO-PSI
Archive
Jeff Scott

Downhole Instrumentation Cable: Encapsulated or Bare? When Does it Matter?

Permanent Downhole Gauge Technology For Cemented-In Completions At GEO PSI we produce some of the worlds best downhole instrumentation sensors. Cementing the pressure sensors in behind the casing is becoming increasingly more common and accounts for a large percentage of our work. A controversial topic seems to be whether to use an encapsulated cable or

Read More »
Downhole-Instrumentation-for-Fracking-Operations-Site-Field-Blue-Sky-GEO-PSI-Blog-Post
Archive
Jeff Scott

Downhole Instrumentation for Fracturing Operations

Communication between Frac wells is common in high well volume operating fields. The effects of this communication can vary from environmental leaks to equipment damage. Having the ability to monitor downhole pressures allows companies to observe pressure changes in nearby wells during frac operations of adjacent wells. Monitoring pressure during the fracturing operation is vital

Read More »

Category

Vertical Integration

Category

Cable Protectors

Category

Top Posts

Category

Artificial Lift

Category

TEC

Category

Downhole Gauges

Looking for a complete fit for purpose solution for your well?

Fill out this short questionnaire and one of our experienced team members will show you a solution designed to match the specific requirements of your application.

Contact Information

Provide us with the necessary contact, and location information.


 

 

Downhole Conditions

Tell us about the downhole environment present in your well.


 

Please describe the type of environment the sensors will be in.

 

 

Packer/Obstruction #1

Packer/Obstruction #2

Packer/Obstruction #3

 

Completion Data

Please provide us with as much information on your specific completion as possible.


Surface Casing

 

Production Casing

2nd Production Casing

Tubing

2nd Tubing

Liner

 

 

Open Hole

 

 

What are the major application(s) for the downhole sensor(s)?

What are your preferred wellhead exit options?

What are the surface electronics required?

 

 

 

 

 

  • Your email is safe with us.

Africa Sales Contact

  • Your email is safe with us.

Europe – MENA Sales Contact

  • Your email is safe with us.

South-Central America Sales Contact

  • Your email is safe with us.

USA Sales Contact

  • Your email is safe with us.

Canada Sales Contact

  • Your email is safe with us.

Asia Pacific Sales Contact

  • Your email is safe with us.